Nonprofit News

Access the latest news in the nonprofit sector.

Sometimes the best way to answer a question is to look at it from another perspective. Our Campbell Chats bring together our diverse team to talk about the toughest questions facing nonprofits today. By looking at these questions from several points of view, we share our expertise with each other—and with the nonprofit world!

Duncan Reilly, Marketing and Business Development Associate: Welcome! Today we’re focusing on one broader topic: Arts organizations’ membership programs and how they integrate with major giving programs.

First question: what keeps membership and major gifts teams from working together? Are they just talking past each other or is something else going on?

Charlotte Cottier, Senior Consultant, Communications: I feel like it’s an issue of different goals. Attendance vs. relationships and major gifts.


Taylor Schmidt, Consultant, Strategic Information Services: I agree with Charlotte. From a data perspective, working with a large population of members in aggregate can be very different than working with a smaller population of major donors in someone's portfolio where there are one-on-one relationships that take place (mostly) outside of a database.

Cassie Carter, Senior Consultant: I think that the membership staff fear that the patrons will be insulted if they get asked to give, so they want to set up a firewall.

 

Fundraising, Communications Strategies, Fundraising Tips, Arts & Culture Trends, Strategic Information Services, Annual Giving, Executive Search

The buying and selling of art – especially contemporary art – has been in the news a lot lately. In May, Christie’s sold over $1 billion of art in just three days. Rival Sotheby’s did well too; its 63 lots of contemporary American art sold for an average of over $6 million each, totaling over $380 million.

Nonprofit Trends, Arts & Culture Trends, Fundraising Tips

For years, nonprofit organizations have motivated high-capacity donors to make leadership gifts by leveraging physical spaces or prestigious endowed positions as naming opportunities, especially during capital and/or endowment campaigns. Historically, these naming rights have been offered in perpetuity, with the legacy of a one-time gift often outlasting a supporter’s relationship to an organization – or outlasting the useful purpose of a space or building altogether.

Campbell & Company News, Arts & Culture Trends, Fundraising Tips, Campbell & Company Research Findings

In the world of memes, mashups, popups and flash mobs, is there still a place for the traditional cultural arts? A panel convened to discuss that for Campbell & Company’s recent webinar, The Future of the Arts: Strategies for Sustainability. Joining the discussion were Robert Alpaugh, Senior Consultant at Campbell & Company; Carroll Joynes, Co-Founder and Director of the Cultural Policy Center, Harris School of Public Policy at the University of Chicago; and Ben Cameron, Program Director of the Arts at the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation.

Campbell & Company News, Nonprofit News, Arts & Culture Trends

Marian Alexander DeBerry, Director of Executive Search, Campbell & Company, quoted in recent MUSEUM article:

In the May-June edition of the American Associations of Museums' (AAM) MUSEUM, author Carl G. Hamm, Deputy Director, Development and External Affairs at Saint Louis Art Museum, and immediate past chair, AAM DAM, discusses the high turnover rate among museums' chief development officers and the lack of quality chief development officer candidates. 

According to a recent study conducted by a national consulting firm, the top development post at more than 25 percent of the art museums holding membership in the Association of Art Museum Directors (AAMD) were either vacant or in the process of being hired. Additionally, the survey revealed that the average tenure of a chief development officer with an organization is 18 to 24 months. As a result, the development position in museums is becoming a "short-term enterprise rather than a strategic institution function".

Mr. Hamm sees various reasons causing this issue. Most important among them:
  • Projects for speedy fund generation as apposed to a long-term sustainable philanthropic-driven program development.
  • Unrealistic expectation of raising a big sum of funds in a short time frame.
  • Exclusion of accomplished mid-level professionals in grant writing, event management, gift officers, planned giving specialists, membership managers, and campaign managers from the organization’s overall budgeting discussions.
“One of the biggest trends we are seeing in hiring chief development officers these days it that the jobs have simply become too big,” says Marian Alexander DeBerry, Director of Executive Search at Campbell & Company. “Organizations are expecting the candidates with broad-based organizational skills, marketing knowledge and campaign experience, not to mention a complete understanding of both the philanthropic process and the ability to orchestrate programs to increase earned revenue.”

Possible solutions voiced among the leading industry minds include:
  • Differentiation between programs designed to generate fast cash and those philanthropic relationships that sustain organizations in the long term.
  • A better understanding of the role philanthropy plays in the life of the organization.
  • Willingness to generate earned revenues in a more innovative and entrepreneurial way.
  • Establishment of realistic expectations from the new chief development officer to produce successful programs.
  • Inclusion of mid-level talent into the discussions about the ongoing matters of the organization.
  • Encouragement of the continuous professional growth among aspiring professionals.
Also, Mr. Hamm warns against eroding from the philanthropic culture, which is essential to the museum field and encourages addressing the issue of qualified high level development professionals properly and promptly. 

For questions about how to retain your top talent, contact Marian Alexander DeBerry.

About Campbell & Company
Campbell & Company is a national consulting firm offering advancement planning, fundraising, marketing communications and executive search services to nonprofit organizations in nearly every sector. Through thirty-six years and more than a thousand engagements, we helped our clients anticipate and manage the challenges of the philanthropic marketplace. Our offices are located in Chicago, Boston, Portland, Los Angeles, the San Francisco Bay Area and Washington, DC. For more information, please call toll-free (877) 957-0000, email info@campbellcompany.com or visitwww.campbellcompany.com.

Talent Management Strategies, Arts & Culture Trends, Nonprofit Trends