You felt so confident sending that draft around – a case statement, a strategic narrative, a new brand anthem, whatever it was. Time for your key stakeholders to bathe in the brilliance of your work, rise to their feet, and slow-clap as they commit their whole hearts to your cause!
Just kidding. Now you have seven different sets of feedback from leadership, board members, and key staff, and you’re wondering if it isn’t too late to consider the skilled trades.
Where to now?
In the nonprofit sector, doing big things means doing things together. If you’re rolling out a campaign, a strategic plan, or a transformational program concept, there are inevitably a lot of people you need to come along with you—and that means giving them a legitimate opportunity to offer input along the way.
What you do with all of that feedback matters enormously—to the ultimate strength of the work, to the support you build around it, and to your own position of leadership (and sanity).
We’ve been through it with countless nonprofit leaders and organizations over the years, and we’ve seen how feedback processes can build stronger work and lasting momentum or go off the rails.
There are no easy hacks, but we’ve pulled together our favorite frameworks here to support you—along with some little examples of what each framework sounds like in a collaborative dialogue.
Asking for feedback might feel like giving up control, but the group still needs you to lead. That means proactively setting the focus and terms of the feedback process, managing the back and forth with genuine curiosity, and making sure all voices are heard. It usually means mostly playing referee and being selective about where you share your own opinion—you have lots of ways to shape the outcome apart from your own “vote” anyway. Most of all, it means continuously refining the path forward, proposing solutions, and knowing when to press for a decision. If you feel yourself getting pushed around or pulled into the role of an order-taker, it may be time to reset the discussion around the larger goals of the project.
“We can take line edits offline – feel free to send those directly to me. For the purposes of our group discussion today, do we feel like the overall message of this opening section is the right idea to rally people around? Could you see yourself riffing on this message in your own words in a donor conversation?”
It isn’t unanimity, and it certainly isn’t “we have no further edits” – that horizon will recede before you no matter how far you pursue it. A group win is when key stakeholders feel that their voices have been heard, the outcome you’ve arrived at is legitimate, and they’re ready to help you move the work forward.
“Do we think we have enough here to start sharing with donors and seeing how it works in practice?”
Every data point has the potential to make your work stronger. Even if the literal suggestion of a particular edit might be a bit clunky, it’s telling you something about where someone got tripped up, and you can work with that in the ways that best serve the project. The key is that all feedback must be interpreted and honored—but it doesn’t always have to be applied literally. Sometimes that means finding a more elegant way to execute a wording edit from your staff that came in too jargony. Sometimes it’s noticing that a theme your board chair lifted up in one place actually needs to be applied in three other places as well. Sometimes it means holding off on a specific edit for now but keeping an eye out for further data on it—does the next audience trip over that same point?
“When we started working with your feedback, we actually found a way to weave XYZ theme throughout rather than just hitting it in that one section—let me show you how that works in the new draft.”
If you start from “defend/resist/explain,” not only might you overlook genuinely useful input, you’ll also probably miss a chance to build trust, and your collaborators will be more likely to fixate on a checklist of specific edits. If you seem genuinely curious about and open to the feedback, you can bring your collaborators onto your side of the table and open up more space for a creative solution that might work even better than the initial suggestion taken literally.
“Oh interesting – and that connects to what so-and-so was saying earlier about XYZ – what if we take those and try something like…”
Any consistent theme that arose in two or three different reviewers’ notes immediately goes to the top of your list—not just because multiple data points inherently carry more weight, but because points of alignment show you exactly where you can get a group win in the next draft. Again—a group win isn’t when there are no further edits; it’s when the group feels good about where they’ve arrived together. If you can deliver on the two or three biggest themes that the group aligned on, you’re basically there—and working through the other one-off edits becomes a lot easier.
“The most consistent theme here is that we need to re-anchor the narrative around community—let’s make that our top priority for the next draft and see how much that changes the overall feeling and flow of the piece.”
Even as you focus on broad themes, you can build a lot of support by making sure each reviewer sees something (and it can be narrow or modest) in the revision that has their fingerprints on it. And it gives you something to thank them for when you send around the new version.
“We also really liked that story idea you suggested—it was feeling a little crowded on the first page, but we found a place for it in the next section where it fits really nicely alongside our organizational story.”
What’s a futon? It’s an awful couch combined with an awful bed. It’s what happens when you make a compromise where you really need to make a choice. This is most important for your highest-level concepts—names and brands, headlines and pillars, vision statements, etc.—where the distilled power and aesthetic integrity of the idea is essential to its impact. If you find yourself pulled between two directions and the path of least resistance is smushing them together, see if you can either align the group around one (and strip the other for parts) or find some new synthesis that works in a different way.
“I’m worried that if we try to combine the two campaign name concepts like that, we’ll lose the integrity and impact of a short, punchy name. Do we think we could align around one and work our favorite aspects of the other into the supporting messaging?”
These might feel like narrow matters of craft—but in a sector that values consensus and stakeholder engagement, they’re also measures of leadership. If you can lead a group to an outcome everyone feels great about, you’ll not only have a stronger final product to show for it – you’ll have people ready to help you bring it to life.